An Ode to Public Libraries

Public libraries are a particular and particularly underrated kind of place. They bring a selection of media together in a physical space, books being the most familiar example. The first reaction might be to question their value in the age of the internet, when so much material is constantly available online at your fingertips. But that very sense of constant availability is a reason to keep these institutions and protect them. A library makes a different kind of access possible: one shaped by a shared collection, a building, and the things a visitor did not originally set out to find.

What a membership buys

The first thing is the membership fee. Here in Berlin, 10€ a year gives you access to a huge catalogue of books, music, films, audiobooks, video games, board games and magazines for all age groups. Berlin’s size has an obvious advantage here: a large share of those titles can be borrowed directly from your local Kiez Library. Most items can be taken home for four weeks, and often be renewed for another month if nobody has requested the medium yet.

That is a practical arrangement, but the price is not the main argument for public libraries. I can borrow almost as many books as I want. For research or low volume special interest publications, it is an especially attractive offer, because actually buying those books often constitutes a substantial investments.

A home collection is limited by the space and the budget you can allocate. A library has neither of those constrains. You gain access to all of it’s contents for brings a larger collection within reach for the cost of membership. But not every book I want to read will be waiting on the librarie’s shelves. But books I cannot borrow locally are easy enough to source from a regular bookshop, and with some design books or foreign language publications I often have to do that anyway. But the library gives me a place to begin, and often lets me find out which books deserve a place on my own shelves.

The value of that arrangement is not only that it makes reading cheaper. A book that might be too expensive to buy on a whim can still be borrowed for long enough to read it and decide if you want to buy it. No strings attached. The library makes a certain amount of curiosity affordable.

A catalogue with its own shape

Another element of interests in public libraries is their selection of works on display and their presentation itself. There are several reasons for that. The range is not tied to commercial success or newness. That means the shelves can include books that are more obscure, more niche, or that are unlikely to make much money but still offer high value to interested readers. A collection assembled for borrowing has room for material that would be harder to justify on a commercial floor if every title had to prove its value through sales.

The catalogue is also not always completely up to date. In some fields, that is a disadvantage. If you want to learn about a subject that changes quickly, current literature matters. But even there, a small trip into the past can be interesting. In many other fields, age is easier to tolerate. If most visitors come for the ideas in a book, a version from the 1980s may be just as useful as a new edition. Or maybe you even discover that the older books have actually the better content. The usefulness of a book does not expire at the same rate as the subject it discusses. Truly timeless books offer arguments, images or ways of thinking that remain worth reading. A library makes the difference visible because the older book is still there alongside newer ones. But let’s be real for a moment, the 1980s are not old in book years…

The commercial catalogue and the library catalogue have different pressures. One has to keep a reader or buyer interested enough to pay for a particular title. The other can hold titles because they contribute to a collection, even if their appeal is limited. I do not know how each library makes those decisions, but as a visitor I notice the result in the variety of what is available.

Wandering without a destination

Libraries also encourage you to leave your internet bubble. That is when you physically browse a library by walking along the shelves to discover something new. Then you are encountering books and subjects you were not looking for, but that somehow found their way to you.

A search begins with a word or a question you already have. But wandering through the aisles gives you something less controlled. The next book you want to read sits beside the one you originally came for. And the one after that may even be about a subject you had not considered at all. You do not have to know its title or decide in advance that it belongs among your interests. It is enough to notice it, take it from of the shelf, and look inside.

That is why my pile of books at the end of a library visit regularly grows to a size that demands a carriage bearing a weight that I cannot possibly carry home. My problem has never been choosing books that interest me. My problem is actually getting to all of them before they are due. I always leave with more than I can manage, even though I already know how this tends to end.

I repeatedly end up with books I have not looked at once. Apart from an initial flick through, they remain unread. That does not make their lending pointless. I chose them because they caught my attention, and perhaps I will see them again or look for them at a later date. But the stack of unread books is not a pile of shame to me. It is an un-library and a small record of how a library can turn diffuse ideas into a collection of possibilities.

Online, a search can be useful and direct. When staying in your bubble you do not even need to search at all, you can just keep scrolling and the algorithms serve more of what you already like. But a physical shelf offers a different path through a collection. It does not guarantee discovery, and it cannot decide what will interest you. But it puts itself within reach, making it easy to follow unexpected thoughts you didn’t know you had. Without you having to enter anything into a search bar.

A coworking space

Public libraries are the classic coworking space. People come together there to browse, or to work on site. Libraries are well suited to writing: they have free internet connections, cafés where things cost little, and workspaces that are large enough and well lit. They are quieter than a fashionable café and louder than a desk at home. It is no surprise that not only students but many writers like working in libraries.

The idea that writers work in libraries may now be an old cliché. Still, many older libraries retain a certain sheen from that time. The atmosphere of the building matters alongside the practical things it provides. A table, light and an internet connection are useful, but so is the sense of being in a place where other people have come to read or work.

At home, the desk is yours, and the quiet is yours too. In a café, conversation and movement are part of the room. The library sits somewhere between those conditions. It offers enough quiet to work, while making it clear that you are sharing the space. The presence of other people is there without requiring conversation. For me, that is part of what makes the library useful as a place to work.

Architecture from beautiful to terrible

As public institutions a lot of public libraries are worth visiting for their architecture alone. But, as with other civic buildings, this ranges from beautiful to terrible. Perhaps that delta is even wider when it comes to libraries. Some smaller neighbourhood branches have a monochrome palette of beige and earthy tones that seems to drain every sense of joy and happiness from the body. At the same time, larger cities have central libraries that appear to have been built above all as architectural statements for visitors of the building itself instead of perusers.

If you are a user of one of those larger libraries, you may be particularly fortunate when the architecture firms in charge have actually included people who use public libraries in their planning and design. That seems like a basic thing to want, but the difference between a building created for the image it projects and one planned with its visitors in mind can be drastic.

The building itself is a large part of the library experience. You see it from the street, enter and find your way around it during all interactions. A beautiful exterior does not by itself make the institution useful. Still, public buildings express decisions about how the public is expected to use them. Libraries are no exception.

The missing marketing

As public institutions, libraries do not depend directly on marketing. But surprisingly little activity makes itself visible from the outside, even though most libraries have a lot to offer. Alongside the core product of borrowable media, there are often readings, events for children, courses ranging from languages to music and literature, study groups, live audio plays and other readings. There are many events for which a little bit more effort in marketing at the immediate neighbourhood level would be very welcome.

When you compare that with the heavily promoted offers from commercial operators in the book space like Amazon or Thalia, the contrast is striking. There is an ebook subscription, Audible, and a children’s book service that sends a personally selected range of new books to the home each month. Each for a monthly fee that is on par with the yearly membership fee for a public library. And a lot of people just aren’t aware that a lot of public libraries have similar offers.

Even though a library is funded by public money, rent and salaries still have to be paid. Economically, it does not make sense to keep individual branches open if visitor numbers fall below a certain point. The institution is public, but that does not mean it can ignore the conditions that determine whether it keeps operating. If people do not know what is available, the activities inside the building may remain invisible to the people who might value them.

The library already has the collection, the rooms and the activities. A little more visibility could help people find their way to them. A flyer is a modest thing, but it can tell someone passing by that there is a reading, a course or a group meeting inside. The services do not become valuable only when they are advertised. But if nobody hears about them, it is harder for them to become part of the life of the neighbourhood.

Keeping the doors open

The case for public libraries is made of ordinary things: a low annual fee, a large catalogue, four weeks with a book, a table where you can work, a shelf that leads you somewhere unexpected. None of these details makes a library perfect. A book may not be there when you want it, an older edition may not suit a fast-changing subject, and a building may be beautiful or dispiriting. The catalogue will not match every need, and I will continue to borrow more books than I can read.

But the library gives those ordinary things a place and a shared structure. It makes an enormous collection available without asking each visitor to buy. It holds books outside the immediate logic of commercial success. It puts them on shelves where one can find them by searching, or by wandering without a destination. It makes room for work, events and people who arrive for different reasons.

The internet makes material constantly available, but availability alone does not create a library. A catalogue, a physical collection and a public place offer another way to encounter media and ideas. The point is not that one form of access replaces every other. It is that the library has qualities worth keeping alongside the convenience of online material.

I go to borrow books, and come back with more than I can carry. I intend to read them, and sometimes do not open them again. I use the library as a place to work, even though I know its architecture can be a pleasure or a frustration. These contradictions do not cancel the value of the institution. They are part of what makes it useful to me.

The question is how many people know what their library can offer, and what would make it easier for them to find out. I am rambling here and have neither researched nor supplied any facts or numbers on attendance, library budgets, staffing or the reach of their programmes. I do not know which forms of promotion libraries have tried, or why some branches may fall below the visitor threshold needed to stay open. Those questions remain unanswered for now. But what is clear from my own visits is that in most libraries there is more vibrant life inside these buildings than the quiet exterior of these institutions suggests, and that the low cost of entry is only the beginning of the offer.