Physical vs digital books
I have an addiction. Browsing through book stores and buying books. Sadly I am by no means as fast in reading books as I am in aquiring them and my “to-be-read” pile is growing relentlessly, which is sometimes a significant financial investment. But I can’t help myself. Despite having a library card and an ebook subscription, I still succumb to the lure of physical books. Despite how often people chant “print is dead”, I just find reading a physical book more satisfying than reading an ebook or a website, because for my way of reading it just offers more convenience. Simply because I am always reading with some sticky notes and pencils nearby and are always marking pages and writing in the margins. Depending on the book I am reading and the mood I am in this can get a little excessive, but it helps me to better internalize the material. Yeah, I can mark pages and add notes in digital books as well but it is to fiddly and always breaks my flow much more than throwing down a line or jotting down a quick idea onto the page with a pen.
But digital books have their advantages and so I appreciate both and sometimes (in rare cases) I even get both versions of a book. Shoutout to all the publishers who hand out download codes with their physical copies. In research, especially, I often wish physical books had a search function like their digital counterparts. But there is something fulfilling about watching yourself work through a book, however thick it is, until you can eventually put it aside.
The physical book gives that effort a visible shape. There are pages left and pages finished. You can see how far you have gone and what remains. And filling it with sticky markers really takes this up to the next level. And finishing a weighty tome with a satisfying “thud” and setting it aside just hits different than closing a web page or putting down your ereader. One offers a sense of having travelled through something with a beginning and an end, the other not so much.
Printed publishing as a quality gate
The most important difference between books and digital writing, including this text, is that books usually pass through several rounds of editing and a proofreading process. Especially when a publisher has produced them, there is a certain degree of quality control. Of course, some published books are rubbish, and there are publishers whose opinions I simply do not share. Even so, most physically produced books of this kind (I am focusing on real publishers and am excluding self-published print on demand titles here.) can be credited with a certain minimum level of quality that many online texts, particularly on blogs or personal sites like this one, often lack.
In defense of online writing and blogs, that difference is largely a question of time. A book takes much longer to develop than a text written and published online in a morning. And not every idea that is enough for a short text is suitable for a whole book. The two forms ask for quite different amounts of work, and not every subject needs the longer, more arduous form.
This is not an argument that print automatically makes a text reliable, or that online writing cannot be careful and fact checked as well. It is an observation about the processes that often surround each format. A book has usually had more time to be edited and checked. A blog post may be immediate, provisional and written by one person. Sometimes that is exactly the right form. But when I pick up a book, I know that several stages may have stood between the first draft and the printed pages.