I keep returning to the same question when thinking about my work. Should I become better at one particular thing, or spend more time learning something else? There are good reasons for both, which is probably why I have not managed to put the question to rest. Time spent getting better at one skill leaves less time to develop another. And while I tend to encourage people to take a broader approach, I find it much harder to follow that advice without wondering what I might be giving up.
This text is also a letter to myself. I am still trying to work out how much room to give my different interests and where I need to commit.
The classic T-Shaped person
From an employer’s point of view, I can see the appeal of a specialist. If you need someone to build an interface, create a concept or engineer an application, a person who has honed that particular task for years is usually preferable to someone who is equally skills in all of the mentioned tasks. Because time is a constrained resource this usually means that neither of those skills is sufficiently developed for bringing real value. Someone who does several things may have more to explain before you understand what you would actually ask them to do. You rather prefer to look at their work and imagine where they would fit into your team.
My impression is that this becomes especially relevant in larger organisations, where work can be divided between people with clearly defined responsibilities. There is a practical reason for that: If you already know what needs doing, hiring someone who has done it many times before makes sense. A broader set of interests still has to be useful for the work at hand.
That is what makes the question difficult. You may want to develop in several directions while looking for a job that asks you to demonstrate one thing very clearly. Both demands can be reasonable, even when they pull you towards different decisions.
What happens when the work changes?
The longer view makes me hesitate about specialising too narrowly. Not least, because the Spectre of AI is looming large on the horizon. There is also the question of what I will want to do afterwards, and what happens if the work I have prepared for changes.
Imagine a programmer or a concept artist whose most practised tasks become easier to automate through AI. Suppose that changes what an employer is willing to pay them to do. The question is what remains available to that person if the task they are known for becomes less valuable to an employer. What else can they do, and which parts of their experience can they bring to different work?
Having other skills could give them more possibilities. It would still take effort to move into a different area, and being broadly interested would not replace the ability to do the work. But I would rather have several things I can build on than feel that everything depends on one particular way of working continuing to be needed.
[Which concrete case could support this concern if the essay is developed beyond the hypothetical?]
Breadth still requires work
There is a difficulty here that I cannot simply explain away by calling myself a generalist. Learning about something and being able to do it are different commitments. Reading about how to play basketball does not make you Michael Jordan. Likewise reading about programming does not mean you can engineer an application. Reading about composition does not make you the designer the project needs. Although those activities certainly helps in bringing you closer to those goals ever so slightly at some point you have to stay with a skill long enough to get through the frustrating and repetitive troughs to a place where you can actually meaningfully contribute to a team effort on a project.
I have already written about this dilemma in getting things done. Wanting to do too much can leave you with work that never quite reaches the point where you are willing to publish it. Starting something else can feel productive while the unfinished thing stays on your hard drive. A broader approach still needs decisions about what you will actually finish.
01
Getting things done
Getting things done and [[shipping-it]] is really hard for me, because I am more of a Pareto guy. I do things [[8020]]. I don’t like to acknowledge it, but I have to come to terms with the fact that I don’t ship enough. …
This makes me question how useful the distinction between generalism and specialism is for deciding what to do tomorrow. You can take a particular project seriously and spend time developing the skills it requires without deciding that this has to become your only area of interest. The immediate commitment can be quite specific, even while your interests remain broad.
Interest is part of the decision
I strongly believe that interest matters when choosing what to learn. If something keeps drawing your attention, you have a reason to return to it after the first excitement has worn off. You start noticing questions you could not have asked at the beginning. That gives you a reason to keep learning beyond putting another skill on your application.
This does not make the need to earn a living disappear. You can be interested in something that offers very little paid work, and you may have responsibilities that limit how much time you can give it. I find it difficult to recommend following your interests without acknowledging that. Having the room to choose is itself a circumstance that not everyone shares.
But I would also be reluctant to choose a direction solely because I thought it would make me easier to employ. If I have little interest in the work itself, how willing will I be to keep improving once learning it becomes difficult? Interest cannot answer every practical question, but I want it to have a place in the decision.
Choosing for now
Even work you care about contains tasks you would rather avoid. Being passionate about a field does not mean enjoying every hour spent working in it. There will still be revisions, repetitive tasks and days when progress is hard to see. I do not think choosing between generalism and specialism will remove any of that.
For now, I want to give a skill enough time to become useful while keeping some room for interests that do not yet have an obvious purpose. That leaves the harder daily decision about what deserves my attention. I still have to choose something to work on, stay with it and finish it. Then I can look at what I have learned and decide where to go next.
Sources
specialism